Christmas Classic First View Review – A Christmas Carol (1938)

Over the years I’ve seen a fair few versions of A Christmas Carol, or Scrooge as it’s sometimes called, but this 1938 version is a new one on me! There’s no point going too deeply into the story because, as both Harold Melvin & The Blue Notes and Simply Red said, “If you don’t know me by now, you will never, never, never know me”.  I feel comfortable saying this because the whole Scrooge and the ghosts story is very well known. If this were a film about an Aristophanes play like Lysistrata or The Women At The Thesmophoria Festival then I wouldn’t assume that everyone would know the storyline.

RunPee’s Big Christmas Movie Hub

——Content continues below——

The World’s Most Indispensable Movie App

The RunPee app tells you the best times to
run & pee during a movie
so you don't miss the best scenes.

As seen on

Download the RunPee app.
100% free (donation supported)

     

Read more about the RunPee app.

So, having decided that everyone who’s still reading this knows at least the bare bones of the story, the obvious next step is to look at this particular version and find out what makes it different. The obvious first step with any film is to look at the cast. For this outing our Ebenezer is played by Reginald Owen. Mr Owen was a replacement for none other than Lionel Barrymore who had read Scrooge for years on the radio. Unfortunately ill health meant he had to drop out. Still, Reginald Owen had been appearing in films since the silent era and would go on into the TV era so the role was in safe hands.

Watch! There’s An Intruder In My Room!

The many film productions of A Christmas Carol adjusted the basic elements of the novel to accommodate the particular stars of their versions. Gene Lockhart was a renowned character actor of this film’s era and thus Bob Cratchit, and his family’s story, received much more screen time than other versions. Similarly, David Warner’s Bob Cratchit also received a lot more screen time in the 1984 version. Kathleen Harrison, playing Mrs. Dilber in 1951, received whole scenes not found in other films or the novel. There is an extra scene added for comedy value; following the arrival of Marley’s ghost, Scrooge calls out the watch. 

The watch arrive like clowns falling out of a car only for the ghost to have disappeared. They leave with plenty of jolly chat about spirits and how they would have enjoyed helping out with them. Incidentally, I recognised Marley’s ghost immediately; it was played by Leo G Carroll who had also played Alexander Waverly in my childhood favourite The Man From U.N.C.L.E. Other differences are things like Bob Cratchit actually getting fired and rehired rather than just getting told off and threatened with dismissal. Fred has a much diminished role but does end up being taken on as Scrooge’s partner. This version also finishes a bit earlier; we see Scrooge joining in the Christmas Day festivities but we don’t go as far as Boxing Day.

Your Intruder Seems To Have Extruded!

I mentioned earlier that Gene Lockhart played Bob Cratchit and how the part was expanded due to his fame at the time. I don’t know whether it was down to whimsey or clever casting but Mrs Cratchit was played by Gene’s real life wife Kathleen Lockhart and the daughter, Belinda Cratchit, marks the debut of June Lockhart in an uncredited role. That doesn’t mean as much though, as this was in the era before the person who stirs the tea got a name check; two cards, one says “The End” and the other lists eleven members of the cast.

Apparently MGM released a record-breaking three hundred and seventy five prints of A Christmas Carol so that as many people as possible could see it during the Christmas season. Remember, young stock, this is the time before digital downloads to cinemas. This is when films were put onto reels and actually taken around in a handcart. They also must have decided that this version was going to be a warmer, fuzzier, family friendly version of the story. We don’t see the sky full of wailing, tortured spirits. Neither do we see the neglected children, Want and Ignorance. We also don’t see Scrooge’s love life falling apart or his clothes and upholstery being sold off after his death.

What people are saying
about the RunPee app.

Nprtykty, 03/28/2021

Brilliant idea with great information

I’ve been using RunPee for a few years now and it’s basically a requirement of going to the movies for me. The best part of course are the “pee times” that give you cues, synopses and times for when you can pee without missing the most important parts of the movie. There is also information about the credits- length, extras and if there are any extra scenes at the wayyy end. Super helpful to just know that it is or isn’t worth staying. There is a timer function that will buzz your phone when it’s a good time to pee. I also appreciate that the app is very conscientious about it being an app you use in a theater- dark background, all silent alarms etc. I will always enjoy the experience of the theater even if I could watch things at home- but I’ve even used it at home to check for things like after credit scenes or other information too.

View all reviews: Apple App Store | Google Play Store

     

Still, all in all a jolly version.

Movie Grade: A-

Quiz – The Lego Batman Movie – Think You Know Your Lego Superhero Quotes?

The Deadpool Before Christmas

Rewatch Review – The Man Who Invented Christmas

Rob Williams

Former teacher, lecturer, homelessness administrator, pharmacy dispenser now happily retired, happily married, and a very happy granddad. I live next to the Mersey but on the side Daniel Craig and Taron Egerton come from rather than the side the Beatles came from!