Children’s Book Review: Harry Cat’s Pet Puppy – A Cricket in Times Square novel

I’ve been really enjoying a re-read of many favorite childhood novels — in some cases a first-time read. Such is the case with Harry Cat’s Pet Puppy (1974), the third book in a series that began with the classic The Cricket in Times Square. As a kid, I adored the Cricket story and never knew there were sequels. I’d have been all over them had I known. So when I uncovered a box of vintage kid’s books, I decided to do ten minutes of a Legs Up The Wall yoga pose each morning, and read ten minutes of these stores. Since the books are only around 150 pages — and many with large hand-drawn illustrations to boot — the reading goes quickly. Many of these have been adapted into movies or TV children’s specials. I’ve been trying to track those down and link to them here on RunPee.

So how is Harry Cat’s Pet Puppy?

To be honest, the quality of characterization dropped a bit by this third novel. I was still engaged in the story, but this time around Tucker Mouse was just too neurotic and Harry Cat was a bit pushy and mean.

The World’s Most Indispensable Movie App

The RunPee app tells you the best times to
run & pee during a movie
so you don't miss the best scenes.

As seen on

Download the RunPee app.
100% free (donation supported)

     

Read more about the RunPee app.

Tucker was always high-strung and energetic, but this time it wasn’t charming — he didn’t use that ‘Mousiekins’ cleverness to save the day, as in the original Cricket and its direct sequel, Tucker’s Countryside. Harry Cat lacked the signature warm nature that made him such a break-out character before. The titular puppy was sullen almost all the time, and the pigeon character was too over-the-top. The Siamese cat was cutely written by the end, but it took a long time for her to become a real character, and it seemed most of the cat interactions were unfortunately off-camera, so to speak.

You can write flawed characters in any book/movie, but you have to provide something interesting about them in the process. They should make you laugh or smile, or be somehow engaging in the thick of things. It’s a tricky matter. Author George Seldon walked that line nicely before. The third time here isn’t a bad story, but isn’t a charm.

There was also no Chester Cricket, in case that’s an important matter for anyone.

Maybe the cricket is a necessary component to make these characters gel properly. Instead of the well-drawn, sensible, kind insect, we have underwritten and overwritten old/new animals.

We also wander all over New York City with a sense of dread and bleakness. Maybe the author was going through a wintry period himself; it’s hard to say. This is a good book with a fine message about abandoned animals and tolerance, but it’s not as magical or fun an outing.

Perhaps the next novels get back to the sense of wonder and enchantment as before. From the title of the next book, Chester Cricket’s Pigeon Ride, it seems we get our favorite insect back. That can’t be a bad thing.

Some cute moments between the animals and a good message keeps this third book in the Cricket series going, but it’s a step down somehow. Harry Cat’s Pet Puppy is still a solid little novel, landing squarely in the B range. 

What people are saying
about the RunPee app.

LBeeCat, 05/27/2022

Movie Watching Must Have!!

I go feral for this app. I love it so much and I wish everyone knew about it and used it. It is incredibly useful and I would be devastated if this app ever disappeared. Things I love: 1) the pee times! It’s so handy to know the best time to go and then read the synopsis of what’s happening while I’m gone. I never have to worry about missing the good bits! 2) knowing if there is a post-credits scene or not. This might be my fav feature because I would have missed out on some pretty critical scenes if it weren’t for RunPee. 3) the movie review and viewer rankings. This info has made me watch some movies that I normally wouldn’t and it’s nice seeing things outside of my usual scope. 4) that it’s a small family run business. I love shopping small and it really does feel like I’m part of the RunPee family! If you reach out to them, Dan will personally respond to you and he is so warm and helpful. GET THIS APP AND THEN SUBSCRIBE! It is absolutely worth it and you’ll be using it again and again!

View all reviews: Apple App Store | Google Play Store

     

Book Grade: B

Children’s Book Review – Tucker’s Countryside (A sequel to The Cricket in Times Square)

Children’s Book Review – Bunnicula

Jill Florio

Co-Creator of RunPee, Chief of Operations, Content Director, and Managing Editor. RunPee Jilly likes galaxy-spanning sci fi, superhero sagas, fantasy films, YA dystopians, action thrillers, chick flicks, and zany comedies, in that order…and possesses an inspiringly small bladder. In fact, that little bladder sparked the creation of RunPee. (Good thing she’s learned to hold it.)