A Harry Potter TV series has been in the works since 2023, and now that 2025 has arrived, we’re finally getting more details and even a tentative release date. The series is expected to begin filming this year and to be a decade-long series that is “a faithful adaptation” of the books. The first season should launch in 2026, airing on HBO and made available to stream on Max. It will be produced by Francesca Gardiner and Mark Mylod, with Gardiner also serving as a writer on the show. The actor cast as Dumbledore has also been announced, with John Lithgow set to play the character. So far, Lithgow is the only cast member revealed, though there is hope that Cillian Murphy will play Voldemort.
Actors from the original films are unlikely to return for the series. Daniel Radcliffe said he didn’t think having the original cast in the show would work, but he was excited about the release. He’s not the only one excited about it, though for many, the excitement is also met with hesitation. There’s a growing fear among Harry Potter fans that while the TV series might bring the story to a new generation, it may also ruin the franchise, primarily due to these four reasons.
The World’s Most Indispensable Movie App
The RunPee app tells you the best times to
run & pee during a movie
so you don't miss the best scenes.
Download the RunPee app.
100% free (donation supported)
1. The Challenge of Replacing the Original Cast
When people think of the characters in the Harry Potter series, they picture the actors who portrayed them in the films. To many fans, no one can compare to Daniel Radcliffe as Harry Potter, Emma Watson as Hermione Granger, Rupert Grint as Ron Weasley, Alan Rickman as Severus Snape, and the list could go on. A new series requires a whole new cast, and finding actors who can fill the shoes of those who have already played beloved Harry Potter characters will be no easy task.
Of course, one hope of retelling the story of the Harry Potter books is to gain a new audience rather than just cater to the existing fan base. Finding new actors, particularly a diverse cast, allows a new generation of fans to identify and grow with the characters and actors.
2. Oversaturation of the Harry Potter Franchise
Since the Harry Potter films were released, Warner Bros. has also released the Fantastic Beasts series, extending the franchise. The films were inspired by the Harry Potter companion book Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them. The first Fantastic Beasts film received decent reviews and raked in a fair amount at the box office, but the following movies seem to have asked too much of Harry Potter fans, as their success dwindled.
Additionally, the franchise includes dozens of video games, companion novels, theme parks, studio tours, and endless merchandise. Many fans fear that the TV series will only serve to harm the franchise by oversaturating it and diluting the impact the original series had amidst all these franchise offers. Just as audiences experienced fatigue from DC and Marvel’s rapid superhero movie releases, they may begin to feel the same way about the Wizarding World of Harry Potter if yet another adaptation is released.
3. The Issue of Retelling the Same Story
Along with worries of oversaturation are concerns about retelling the same story so quickly after its movie adaptation was completed. Although the movies omitted some characters and details, they stayed true to the original story. If the TV series also intends to follow the books, will it resonate so soon with audiences when the story is still relatively fresh in their minds? The Warner Bros. franchise doesn’t need to rush to recreate the story as a TV series when it’s only recently (in 2011) concluded the movie adaptation. The Harry Potter story is not a fleeting trend or a limited-time offer code like the one you might get when gaming or shopping online. The story will still be available to explore again after audiences have had more time for nostalgia to build.
What people are saying
about the RunPee app.
September 23, 2023
This app is the best wingman for a movie goer, especially when you have to go. It even has a vibrating timer that is spot on for those ‘go times’ some of us need! There are many other features that are wonderful. It even lets you know when the kill scenes are coming up for the people and animals for those who may have sensitivities to that type of content. The staff go above and beyond!
View all reviews
Apple App Store | Google Play Store
Download RunPee app
Some existing Harry Potter fans have expressed hope that the franchise might try a spinoff TV show, like how the Lord of the Rings franchise created The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power. It added to the original story by providing a prequel to the original story that captivated fans. One idea pitched in Slash Film was to tell the story of the Marauders—Sirius Black, Remus Lupin, Peter Pettigrew, and James Potter—who created the Marauder’s Map that Harry used in many of his adventures. It would be a chance to add to the story and the Wizarding World without relying on the same narrative.
4. Rowling’s Controversies and Their Impact
The Harry Potter author, J.K. Rowling, became a widely celebrated public figure after writing a book series that made her a billionaire after living for years in poverty. Her life was an inspiring rags-to-riches story. However, 2017 marked a divisive shift for Harry Potter fans. Speculation began to grow that Rowling was transphobic or, worse, a TERF (trans-exclusionary radical feminist). The speculation proved to be valid in 2019 when the author posted a tweet to Twitter (now X) supporting transphobic attitudes. Since then, the author has shared many more messages with similar views.
Fans who grew up with Harry Potter and loved its message of acceptance, compassion, and equality were deeply hurt and disappointed by Rowling’s comments. Her actions have prompted many in the LGBTQ+ community and its allies to boycott the franchise. Many actors from the Harry Potter films, including Daniel Radcliffe and Emma Watson, have spoken out against Rowling’s comments and distanced themselves from the author.
Rowling is actively involved in producing the Harry Potter television series and remains outspoken on her controversial views. This controversial behavior may prompt many to dismiss the series and anything else created by the franchise.
Conclusion: Is It Worth the Risk?
Given the huge shoes left to fill by the movie adaptation of the books, the oversaturation of the franchise, the retelling of a well-known story, and the controversies surrounding Rowling, a Harry
Potter TV series will face many challenges in order to succeed. It may resonate with a new generation of Potterheads, but for longtime fans, only time will tell if the show succeeds.
Leave a Reply